Bullock (1975)

(page numbers in brackets)

Notes on the text

Preliminary pages (i-xxxvi)
Foreword, Membership, Contents, Introduction

Part 1 Attitudes and Standards
Chapter 1 (3-9)
Attitudes to the teaching of English
Chapter 2 (10-35)
Standards of reading
Chapter 3 (36-44)
Monitoring

Part 2 Language in the Early Years
Chapter 4 (47-50)
Language and learning
Chapter 5 (51-74)
Language in the early years

Part 3 Reading
Chapter 6 (77-96)
The reading process
Chapter 7 (97-114)
Reading in the early years
Chapter 8 (115-123)
Reading: the later stages
Chapter 9 (124-138)
Literature

Part 4 Language in the Middle and Secondary Years
Chapter 10 (141-161)
Oral language
Chapter 11 (162-187)
Written language
Chapter 12 (188-193)
Language across the curriculum

Part 5 Organisation
Chapter 13 (197-212)
The primary and middle years
Chapter 14 (213-219)
Continuity between schools
Chapter 15 (220-237)
The secondary school
Chapter 16 (238-242)
LEA advisory services

Part 6 Reading and Language Difficulties
Chapter 17 (245-265)
Screening, diagnosis and recording
Chapter 18 (266-276)
Children with reading difficulties
Chapter 19 (277-283)
Adult literacy
Chapter 20 (284-295)
Children from families of overseas origin

Part 7 Resources
Chapter 21 (299-313)
Books
Chapter 22 (314-327)
Technological aids and broadcasting

Part 8 Teacher Education and Training
Chapter 23 (331-346)
Initial training
Chapter 24 (347-356)
In-service education

Part 9 The Survey
Chapter 25
I Introduction (359-365)
II Primary Commentary (365-402)
III Secondary Commentary (402-443)
IV Questionnaire Tables (444-502)
V Technical Notes (502-510)

Part 10 Sumary of Conclusions and Recommendations
Chapter 26 (513-560)
Conclusions and recommendations

Appendix A (561-576)
Witnesses and sources of evidence
Appendix B (577-584)
Visits made

Glossary (585-595)
Index (596-609)


The Bullock Report (1975)
A language for life

Report of the Committee of Enquiry appointed by the Secretary of State for Education and Science under the Chairmanship of Sir Alan Bullock FBA

London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office 1975
© Crown copyright material is reproduced with the permission of the Controller of HMSO and the Queen's Printer for Scotland.

Chapter 25 continued


[page 444]

IV THE QUESTIONNAIRE FORMS

25.32 We reproduce here the questionnaire forms sent to the schools, together with the replies* we received.

The questionnaire falls into six separate parts:

Primary:Part I School Section
Part II Class Section - 6 year olds
Class Section - 9 year olds

Secondary:

Part I School Section
Part II Class Section-12 year olds
Class Section-14 year olds

When the Primary and Secondary Questionnaires were despatched to the schools the School Section was addressed to the head to complete in relation to the school as a whole. The Class Sections were to be completed by the class teachers of 6 and 9 year olds, or by the English teachers in the case of 12 and 14 year olds. In the following pages each of the four class sections is preceded by the relevant Explanatory Notes which were addressed in the first instance to the head of the school, who was then requested to pass them on to the appropriate teacher.

*It will be noted that some boxes contain an "X" rather than a number. This is because the nature of the question was such that an aggregate number for all the respondents would provide meaningless information.


[page 445]

COMMITTEE OF INQUIRY INTO READING AND THE USE OF ENGLISH

PRIMARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOLS QUESTIONNAIRE

Please ensure that every box or set of boxes is completed, either with a number or with a tick as appropriate.

PART I SCHOOL SECTION

I. General

LEA ................................... LEA Number ...............
School .............................. School Number ...............
Head ..............................
Telephone ..............................

School Type (please tick one box only)

Infant207
First45
Infant with Junior475
First and Middle5
Junior194
Middle10

Number of full-time pupils on the roll on 25 January 1973 (as Form 7)214,494
Number of part-time pupils on the roll on 25 January 1973 (as Form 7)11,974
Total number of registration classes16,936

II The Teachers

A1 Number of full-time qualified teachers (including Head)7,917
  2 Number of part-time qualified teachers977
  3 Number of part-time qualified teachers as full-time equivalents (please round to the nearest whole number)477
B1 Number of peripatetic qualified teachers (not included at IIA) who visit this school among others at least weekly to assist and advise in the teaching of reading188
  2 Total number of sessions spent by such teachers in this school in a normal week470


[page 446]

C1 Excluding the Head, how many teachers on the staff, receiving payments above Scale 1, have a special responsibility for the following (do not include teachers with only graduate or E.P.A. allowances)

  a organising the school library402
  b the teaching of poor readers197
  c advising other teachers in the teaching of English192
  2 How many different teachers are included in C1704

D How many teachers altogether, excluding the Head, receive payments above Scale 1?
2772

III School Affiliations

A Does the school or any member of staff belong to

% YESYesNo
1 United Kingdom Reading Association5.652884
2 National Association for the Teaching of English4.744892
3 School Library Association12.5117819
4 Association for the Education of Pupils from Overseas?1.918918

B Have any members of the staff made use of a Teachers' Centre in connection with the teaching of English since September 1972?

% YESYesNo
58.1544392


[page 447

IV Audio-Visual Aids

A Are any of these items used in the teaching of English? Please tick those items of which the school possesses examples that are used in the teaching of the English language and of reading.

% YESYesNo
1 Record player76.3714222
2 Mains tape recorder79.8747189
3 Battery tape recorder42.4397539
4 Filmstrip/slide/loop projector57.3536400
5 Film projector23.2217719
6 Radio87.9823113
7 Television set83.1778158
8 Language Master11.3106830
9 Talking Page1.615921
10 Synchrofax2.221915
11 Other teaching machines?8.479857

B Which of the following are used by the school in the teaching of reading

% YESYesNo
1 Initial Teaching Alphabet9.185851
2 Colour coded schemes5.955881
3 Diacritical marking1.918918
4 Key words reading scheme (e.g. Ladybird)78.9736200
5 Other controlled vocabulary (e.g. Janet and John)89.0833103
6 Breakthrough to Literacy31.3293643
7 Reading laboratories (e.g. S.R.A., Ward Lock)25.3237699
8 Stott's Programmed Reading Kit?29.6277659


[page 448]

V Testing

A Are any of the following tests used in your school

% YESYesNo
1 Burt Rearranged Word Reading Test34.3321615
2 Schonell Graded Word Reading Test72.5679257
3 Schonell Silent Reading Test A24.8232704
4 Schonell Silent Reading Test B23.9224712
5 Vernon Graded Word Reading Test3.634902
6 Holborn Reading Scale27.2255681
7 N.F.E.R. Reading Test AD15.1141795
8 Neale Analysis of Reading Ability16.6155781
9 Standard Test of Reading Skill (Daniels and Diack)17.7166770
10 Word Recognition Test (Carver)1.514922
11 Group Reading Test (Young)6.157879
12 Southgate Group Reading Test 1 - Word Selection6.763873
13 Southgate Group Reading Test 2 - Sentence Completion4.542894
14 Other17.3162774
15 None?7.469867

B Is it the school's policy to test children with published tests of reading

% YESYesNo
1 During their first term in the school23.7222714
2 During their last year in the school66.2620316
3 At some other point during their time in the school?75.2704232


[page 449]

C Are any children receiving special help in reading this term because they fell below chosen test scores?

YesNoN/A
XXX

VI Classes or Groups for Poor Readers (including classes or groups in centres away from the school).

A Total number of special (or remedial) registration classes for children who are poor readers - excluding those specially for children whose first language is not English X

B In some schools children are taught for part of the time in classes, groups or individually outside the registration classes.
(This question does not refer to group work within the class unless an additional teacher is brought in.)

1 Is this being done this term in your school for the teaching of reading Please tick appropriate box

a throughout the full age rangeX
b for part of the age rangeX
c not at all?X

2 Is the rearrangement across the whole ability range? (i.e. are the average and above average readers separated out into groups of similar attainment as well as the poor readers?)

YesNoN/A
XXX

3 Total number of 'remedial' (or withdrawal) groups this term

3,816

C If you have one or more registration classes or withdrawal groups for poor readers (as described in VI.A and VI.B)

1 What is the total number of children taught in such classes or groups?22,762
2 How many children attend the largest of these classes or groups? (If children are always withdrawn individually the number should be 1)X
3 What was the age last birthday of the youngest child in any of these classes or groups?X


[page 450]

4a How many teachers are engaged in teaching these classes or groups?813
  b Of these, how many are part-time in this school?557
  c How many of the teachers engaged in teaching these groups or classes have attended a relevant full-time course (or its part-time equivalent).
    i lasting at least 6 months95
    ii lasting 6 weeks or more, but less than 6 months99
    iii lasting less than 6 weeks382
    iv None?237

(Please show each teacher once only.)

The Committee of Inquiry would welcome any additional information or opinion which you feel may be of help. A space is provided below.

PRIMARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOL QUESTIONNAIRE: 6 YEAR OLDS

Explanatory Notes

1. The Primary and Middle School Questionnaire is in 2 parts, one to be answered for the school as a whole and headed SCHOOL SECTION, the other relating to certain classes or children within the school and headed CLASS SECTION. Several copies of the latter are enclosed so that one can be completed for each of the relevant classes.

2. The relevant classes are those that contain at least 5 children who were 6 but not 7 on 31 August 1972. If there are fewer than 5 children of the age group in a class, that class should not be included in the survey unless it contains all the children of the relevant age group in the school.

3. It is assumed that the SCHOOL SECTION will be filled in by the Head, or under his/her direct supervision. Each CLASS SECTION is to be filled in by the teacher mainly responsible for the group of children to whom it refers. If 2 or more teachers share the responsibility equally, the teacher whose name is first alphabetically should be the one chosen. It would be helpful to the class teachers if the L.E.A. and school numbers could be filled in at the beginning of the class sections before they are handed over.

4. 25 January has been chosen as the collecting date for certain information because the same figures will need to be returned in Form 7. Unfortunately


[page 451]

it is not possible to use the information directly from Form 7 because the Committee's survey will have to be processed before the Form 7 material, which covers all schools, can be made available.

5. It is expected that the survey will provide information about the range of teaching practices used in language work (other than a foreign language) with children of the age group. There is no supposition that the survey will say anything about quality, of which the Committee will gain evidence from visits to a smaller number of schools. Nor will the questionnaire returns from a particular school necessarily represent a full range of the work in that school. It is accepted that where a question has to be answered about an individual child the reply may not be typical even of the class. A large number of schools is included in the survey, and the replies should give a fair picture of what is happening over the country as a whole during the week of the survey. Individual returns from schools will not be quoted.

6. The information given about the school as a whole and about teachers and children will be treated confidentially. The names and telephone numbers have been asked for only in case any query should arise during the processing that requires further information. No names will be transferred to other records.

7. The questionnaire aims to discover what happens in schools. The fact that a question is asked does not imply that the Committee has already adopted a particular view about what should happen.

8. It will be found helpful to read the questionnaire throughout before answering. All questions should be answered by completing the boxes on the right-hand side of each page, entering a number or tick as appropriate. Please ignore the small numbers printed beside some of the boxes. No entries should be made in the right-hand margin.

9. If when completing the questionnaire you should have any difficulty that cannot be resolved in the school, please telephone the Department of Education and Science, Elizabeth House, York Road, London SE1 (telephone 01-928-9222) and ask for the Bullock Committee Survey (ext. 3518).

10. If the number of class sections you have received is insufficient, please ask your L.E.A. for further copies.

PRIMARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOL QUESTIONNAIRE: 6 YEAR OLDS

Class Section

1. Separate returns should be made for each registration class that contains at least 5 children who were 6 but not 7 on 31 August 1972. If the school as a whole contains fewer than 5 such children a return should be made for the registration class of which they are members.

2. This return should be completed by the teacher mainly responsible for the registration class to which it refers. If two or more teachers share the responsibility equally, the one present whose name is first alphabetically


[page 452]

should make the return, with the help of the others where necessary. Information about the teacher (e.g. courses attended) should be answered only in relation to the teacher making the return.

3. The questionnaire aims to discover what happens in schools. This may of course be less than teachers who work in disadvantageous circumstances would like to do. The fact that a question is asked does not mean that the Committee has formed a view about the practice implied.

Please ensure that every box or set of boxes is completed either with a number or a tick as appropriate.

PART II CLASS SECTION

I General

A LEA ..................... LEA Number ...................

B School ................ School Number ..................

C Name of Class .........................
(If the class is known by the name of a teacher, please give that)

D Number of children on the class register on 25 January 1973

X

E Number of children on the class register that day who were 6 but not 7 on 31 August 1972

29,886

F How many OTHER registration classes in the school contain children of this age?

X

G The age range within this registration class is

Please tick appropriate box

%
6 months or less10.5149
between 6 months and 1 year38.5546
more than 1 year50.9722

H Would you describe this class as vertically grouped? (i.e. a class deliberately chosen with an age range of at least 18 months)

% YESYesNo
22.73221,095


[page 453]

II The Teacher

The questions in this section should be answered with reference to the teacher making the replies.

A For how long have you taught in this school (if you have had a break of service of 1 year or more, count the time since the break)?

Please tick appropriate box

%
less than 1 year18.3260
1 to 3 years32.5461
more than 3 years49.1696

B Have you, since becoming a qualified teacher, attended a course lasting 6 months full-time or more than 1 year part-time mainly about one or more aspects of teaching English?

% YESYesNo
1.6231,394

C Have you, since becoming a qualified teacher, and within the last 3 years, attended a course mainly about the teaching of one or more aspects of English lasting

% YESYesNo
1 From 30 days to 6 months full-time or 6 months to 1 year part-time1.6221,395
2 Shorter than any of the periods above, but of at least 6 half-days or sessions?28.54041,013

III. Time spent on English work during the week beginning 22 January 1973

This section should be answered in relation to the boy OR girl present for the whole week whose name is first alphabetically (not necessarily first on the register). It is appreciated that the times shown may not be typical of the class as a whole but the intention is to obtain a picture of the range of times for individual children across the country as a whole. Perhaps the child selected (say Albert Aaron) joined in the class poetry lesson on Wednesday afternoon and then, during other times when the children were being given a choice of activities, spent some time reading poetry to himself on Thursday morning, and writing a poem on Friday. The Wednesday time should be entered under "Class Time" i.e. when everyone was engaged on more or less the same kind of activity: the Thursday and Friday times should be entered


[page 454]

under "Optional Time (Estimated)" because some children may have been engaged on poetry but others in work associated with other parts of the curriculum. Any time recorded below should be entered once only.

A Please complete the following


[page 455]


[page 456]

B Is the child you have referred to above

Please tick appropriate box

%
a a good reader for his age30.8437
b an average reader for his age47.0666
c a poor reader for his age?22.2314

(a = top 25%, b = middle 50%, c = bottom 25%)

C How many teachers teach the child (counting all subjects) during a normal school week?

2.2 average per week 3,082

D Whether or not you have entered "Class Times" above, is it normal for children in the class to do their 'basic work' (or 'skills') mainly during the morning sessions?

% YESYesNo
73.61,043374

IV Ways of Teaching Reading

A The general approach

Were any of the following approaches used in the class with any of the children during the week beginning 22 January 1973:

% YESYesNo
1 Alphabetic analysis (letter names)59.5843574
2 Look and Say (word recognition)96.61,36948
3 Phonic I (letter sounds, digraphs, diphthongs)97.21,37740
4 Phonic 2 (based on syllables)69.7987430
5 Sentence method51.4728689
6 Pre-reading exercises (e.g. to establish left to right eye movement)?35.4501916

B How many children in the class are still in the early stages of learning to read-a reading age of about 5½ or less?

31%    9,252*

*This figure includes a number of 5 year olds in vertically grouped classes.


[page 457]

C How often do the following children in the class normally read to a teacher during a week

Daily3 or 4
times
1 or 2
times
Less
often
1 the ablest reader in the class24651058279
2 an average reader in the class4387612162
3 the poorest reader in the class?1,009375321

D Graded reading schemes

Please tick one box only

1 Does reading practice rely on

%
a one single, commercially produced, graded reading scheme19.0269
b a mixture of books arranged in order by the school and drawing from more than one commercially produced scheme and/or books not in set schemes52.8748
c books and materials none of which are arranged in an order of difficulty either by the publishers or the school0.46
d a mixture of b and c?27.8394

2 Are the children expected to read from these books

Daily3 or 4
times
weekly
1 or 2
times
weekly
Less
often
Not
applic-
able
1,04931142123
74.0%21.9%3.0%0.8%0.2%

3 Movement from stage to stage

a Is it usual for children to read supplementary readers between able the major steps of the graded series?

% YESYesNoNot
applicable
78.31,11026938


[page 458]

Whether the books are graded or not

b Are the children usually tested by the teacher before they move from one book to the next?

% YESYesNo
87.61,241176

c Do some poor readers ever have to repeat a book

Please tick one box only

i more than once41
ii once458
iii never?918

d Is phonic practice given when appropriate to overcome individual weaknesses detected when the teacher is listening to reading?

% YESYesNoNot
applicable
96.81,3712917

(If you have a systematic class programme for phonic work it will have appeared under IV A)

V. Books

This section is intended to reveal what books are available to the children other than graded or supplementary readers, sets of readers, and text books.

A 1 May children borrow, for their individual use in school, books of fiction and poetry from collections

% YESYesNo
a in the classroom98.11,39027
b elsewhere in the school (e.g. central library, corridor, etc.)?76.51,084333

2 May the children borrow books of reference for their use in school from collections

% YESYesNo
a in the classroom96.11,36255
b elsewhere in the school?81.81,159258

3 How many books did the sample child ("Albert Aaron") have in his/her care at the end of the school


[page 459]

day on 25 January, 1973? (If books are returned to the shelves each day, show the number of books the child had immediately before their return.)

3,586
Average 2.5 books per pupil.

4 Are the children allowed to borrow books from elsewhere in the school

% YESYesNo
a at set times19.92821,135
b at any time with the class teacher's agreement?81.81,149268

5 Are books on loan from the L.E.A./County/County Borough Library?

% YESYesNo
79.41,125292

6 Are the children allowed to take any books for use at home?

% YESYesNo
79.71,130287

7 Are any facilities provided in school to enable children or their parents to buy books?

% YESYesNo
16.32311,186

VI Record Keeping

A Are records kept of

% YESYesNo
1 the books read by each child95.51,35364
2 the occasions when a child has read to a teacher93.91,33087
3 persistent individual weaknesses that require help from
  (i) specialist teachers of reading in the school36.7520897
  (ii) specialist teachers of reading and/or educational psychologists outside the school31.6448969
4 assessments of written work?46.5659758


[page 460]

B Are examples of a child's written work kept from year to year as a progress record, either by the teacher or more centrally?

% YESYesNo
39.0553864

VII The Children's Work

A Which of the following were the subject of poetry, prose or play writing in his/her own words by the sample child ("Albert Aaron") during the week beginning 22 January, 1973?

% YESYesNo
1 Original stories64.6915502
2 Stories or information rewritten in the child's own words75.41,068349
3 Model making or work in art and craft41.3585832
4 Personal investigations in connection with science or mathematics36.4516901
5 Other aspects of the child's daily life in or out of school82.61,171246
B When the children are writing in their own words do they

% YESYesNo
1 ask the teacher for help with spelling98.71,39918
2 use word lists displayed about the room87.61,242175
3 use printed dictionaries, including picture dictionaries?82.81,174243


[page 461]

C1 Is it the practice to give an assessment in writing of at least one piece of written work each week (e.g. 6/10:satisfactory)?

% YESYesNo
8.41191,298

2 Are some spelling errors marked each week?

% YESYesNo
87.51,240177

(i) Are children expected to learn to spell words from examples of their own errors and/or the errors made by other children in the class and/or lists made by the teacher?

% YESYesNo
75.01,063354

(ii) Are the children required to learn to spell words from commercially produced lists?

% YESYesNo
6.8961,321

(iii) Are the children tested to see that they have learnt these spellings

Please tick one box only

%
a weekly16.9239
b less often29.1413
c not at all?54.0765

D 1 Are errors of usage (punctuation, grammar, etc.) marked in at least some of the children's writing each week?

% YESYesNo
87.81,244173

2a Are errors made by the children used as subjects for teaching to the whole class, or to a substantial part of it?

% YESYesNo
55.1781636

b Are these errors used as a basis for individual teaching, i.e. teaching the child who made the error?

% YESYesNo
92.01,303114

3 During the week beginning 22 January, 1973 was any planned attempt made to extend the children's vocabulary by any of the following means


[page 462]

% YESYesNo
a exercises requiring the use of dictionaries31.6447970
b vocabulary exercises49.6703714
c class discussion based on
  (i) new materials introduced into the classroom83.31,180237
  (ii) a book or topic chosen partly for that purpose?82.71,172245

PRIMARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOL QUESTIONNAIRE: 9 YEAR OLDS

Explanatory Notes

1. The Primary and Middle School Questionnaire is in 2 parts, one to be answered for the school as a whole and headed SCHOOL SECTION, the other relating to certain classes or children within the school and headed CLASS SECTION. Several copies of the latter are enclosed so that one can be completed for each of the relevant classes.

2. The relevant classes are those that contain at least 5 children who were 9 but not 10 on 31 August, 1972. If there are fewer than 5 children of the age group in a class, that class should not be included in the survey unless it contains all the children of the relevant age group in the school.

3. It is assumed that the SCHOOL SECTION will be filled in by the Head, or under his/her direct supervision. Each CLASS SECTION is to be filled in by the teacher mainly responsible for the group of children to whom it refers. If 2 or more teachers share the responsibility equally the teacher whose name is first alphabetically should be the one chosen. It would be helpful to the class teachers if the L.E.A. and school numbers could be filled in at the beginning of the class sections before they are handed over.

4. 25 January has been chosen as the collecting date for certain information because the same figures will need to be returned in Form 7. Unfortunately it is not possible to use the information directly from Form 7 because the Committee's survey will have to be processed before the Form 7 material, which covers all schools, can be made available.

5. It is expected that the survey will provide information about the range of teaching practices used in language work (other than a foreign language) with children of the age group. There is no supposition that the survey will say anything about quality, of which the Committee will gain evidence from visits to a smaller number of schools. Nor will the questionnaire returns from a particular school necessarily represent a full range of the work in that school. It is accepted that where a question has to be answered about an individual child the reply may not be typical even of the class. A large


[page 463]

number of schools is included in the survey, and the replies should give a fair picture of what is happening over the country as a whole during the week of the survey. Individual returns from schools will not be quoted.

6. The information given about the school as a whole and about teachers and children will be treated confidentially. The names and telephone numbers have been asked for only in case any query should arise during the processing that requires further information. No names will be transferred to other records.

7. The questionnaire aims to discover what happens in schools. The fact that a question is asked does not imply that the Committee has already adopted a particular view about what should happen.

8. It will be found helpful to read the questionnaire throughout before answering. All questions should be answered by completing the boxes on the right-hand side of each page, entering a number or tick as appropriate. Please ignore the small numbers printed beside some of the boxes. No entries should be made on the right-hand margin.

9. If when completing the questionnaire you should have any difficulty that cannot be resolved in the school, please telephone the Department of Education and Science, Elizabeth House, York Road, London S.E.1. (telephone: 01-928-9222) and ask for the Bullock Committee Survey (ext. 3518).

10. If the number of class sections you have received is insufficient, please ask your L.E.A. for further copies.

PRIMARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOL QUESTIONNAIRE: 9 YEAR OLDS

Class Section

1. Separate returns should be made for each registration class that contains at least 5 children who were 9 but not 10 on 31 August 1972. If the school as a whole contains fewer than 5 such children a return should be made for the registration class of which they are members.

2. This return should be completed by the teacher mainly responsible for the registration class to which it refers. If two or more teachers share the responsibility equally, the one present whose name is first alphabetically should make the return, with the help of the others where necessary. Information about the teacher (e.g. courses attended) should be answered only in relation to the teacher making the return.

3. The questionnaire aims to discover what happens in schools. This may of course be less than teachers who work in disadvantageous circumstances would like to do. The fact that a question is asked does not mean that the Committee has formed a view about the practice implied.


[page 464]

Please ensure that every box or set of boxes is completed either with a number or a tick as appropriate.

PART II SCHOOL SECTION

I. General

A LEA ................................... LEA Number ...............

B School .............................. School Number ...............

C Name of Class ..............................
(If the class is known by the name of a teacher, please give that)

D Number of children on the class register on 25 January 1973X

E Number of children on the class register that day who were 9 but not 10 on 31 August, 1972
28466

F How many OTHER registration classes in the school contain children of this age?
X

G The age range within this registration class is %

(Please tick appropriate box)

6 months or less4.252
between 6 months and 1 year46.8587
more than 1 year49.0614

H Would you describe this class as vertically grouped? (i.e. a class deliberately chosen with an age range of at least 18 months)

% YESYesNo
27.8348905

II The Teacher

The questions in this section should be answered with reference to the teacher making the replies.

A For how long have you taught in this school (if you have had a break of service of I year or more, count the time since the break)?

Please tick appropriate box

less than 1 year20.8261
1 to 3 years32.2404
more than 3 years46.9588


[page 465]

B Have you, since becoming a qualified teacher, attended a course lasting 6 months full-time or more than 1 year part-time mainly about one or more aspects of teaching English?

% YESYesNo
2.2391,214

C Have you, since becoming a qualified teacher, and within the last 3 years, attended a course mainly about the teaching of one or more aspects of English lasting

% YESYesNo
1 from 30 days to 6 months full-time or 6 months to 1 year part-time2.2271,226
2 shorter than any of the periods above, but of at least 6 half-days or sessions?25.2316937

III Time spent on English work during the week beginning 22 January 1973

This section should be answered in relation to the boy OR girl present for the whole week whose name is first alphabetically (not necessarily first on the register). It is appreciated that the times shown may not be typical of the class as a whole but the intention is to obtain a picture of the range of times for individual children across the country as a whole. Perhaps the child selected (say Albert Aaron) joined in the class poetry lesson on Wednesday afternoon and then, during other times when the children were being given a choice of activities, spent some time reading poetry to himself on Thursday morning, and writing a poem on Friday. The Wednesday time should be entered under "Class Time", i.e. when everyone was engaged on more or less the same kind of activity: the Thursday and Friday times should be entered under "Optional Time (Estimated)" because some children may have been engaged on poetry but others in work associated with other parts of the curriculum. Any time recorded below should be entered once only.


[page 466]

A Please complete the following:


[page 467]


[page 468]

B Is the child you have referred to above

Please tick appropriate box

%
a a good reader for his age41.1515
b an average reader for his age37.4469
c a poor reader for his age?21.5269

(a=top 25%, b=middle 50%, c=bottom 25%)

C How many teachers teach the child (counting all subjects) during a normal school week?

3,961    3.2 average per week

D Whether or not you have entered "Class Times" above, is it normal for children in the class to do their 'basic work' (or 'skills') mainly during the morning sessions?

% YESYesNo
80.51,009244

IV Ways of Teaching Reading

A The general approach

Were any of the following approaches used in the class with any of the children during the week beginning 22 January 1973:

%YesNo
1 Alphabetic analysis (letter names)31.3392861
2 Look and Say (word recognition)67.0840413
3 Phonic 1 (letter sounds, digraphs, diphthongs)73.7924329
4 Phonic 2 (based on syllables)70.9889364
5 Sentence method30.7385868
6 Pre-reading exercises (e.g. to establish left to right eye movement)?5.3661,187

B How many children in the class are still in the early stages of learning to read - a reading age of about 7 or less?

10.7%    3,035

C How often do the following children in the class normally read to a teacher during a week


[page 469]

Daily3 or 4
times
weekly
1 or 2
times
weekly
Less
often
1 the ablest reader in the class1553443742
2 an average reader in the class34244797178
3 the poorest reader in the class?59947216418

D Graded reading schemes

Please tick one box only

1 Does reading practice rely on

% YES
a one single, commercially produced, graded reading scheme6.075
b a mixture of books arranged in order by the school and drawing from more than one commercially produced scheme and/or books not in set schemes37.1465
c books and materials none of which are arranged in an order of difficulty either by the publishers or the school2.936
d a mixture of band c?54.0677

2 Are the children expected to read from these books

Daily3 or 4
times
weekly
1 or 2
times
weekly
Less
often
Not
applic-
able
7353521312114
58.7%28.1%10.5%1.7%1.1%

3 Movement from stage to stage

a Is it usual for children to read supplementary readers between the major steps of the graded series?

% YESYesNoNot
applic-
able
61.3768223262


[page 470]

Whether the books are graded or not

b Are the children usually tested by the teacher before they move from one book to the next?

% YESYesNo
77.0965288

c Do some poor readers ever have to repeat a book

Please tick one box only

i more than once541
ii once376
iii never?823

d Is phonic practice given when appropriate to overcome individual weaknesses detected when the teacher is listening to reading?

% YESYesNoNot
applic-
able
91.61,1486738

(If you have a systematic class programme for phonic work it will have appeared under IV A)

V Books

This section is intended to reveal what books are available to the children other than graded or supplementary readers, sets of readers and text books.

A 1 May children borrow, for their individual use in school, books of fiction and poetry from collections

% YESYesNo
a in the classroom94.91,18964
b elsewhere in the school (e.g. central library, corridor, etc.)?81.61,022231

2 May the children borrow books of reference for their use in school from collections

% YESYesNo
a in the classroom93.91,17677
b elsewhere in the school (e.g. central library, corridor, etc.)?89.51,122131

3 How many books did the sample child ("Albert Aaron") have in his/her care at the end of the school day on 25 January 1973? (If books are returned to the shelves each day, show the number of books the child had immediately before their return.)

4,584    Average 3.7 books per pupil


[page 471]

4 Are the children allowed to borrow books from elsewhere in the school

% YESYesNo
  a at set times24.6308945
  b at any time with the class teacher's agreement?88.71,111142

5 Are books on loan from the LEA/County/County Borough Library?
87.41,095158

6 Are the children allowed to take any books for use at home?
92.61,16093

7 Are any facilities provided in school to enable children or their parents to buy books?
27.2341912

VI Record Keeping

A Are records kept of

% YESYesNo
1 the books read by each child78.2980273

2 the occasions when a child has read to a teacher
69.6872381

3 persistent individual weaknesses that require help from
  i specialist teachers of reading in the school46.4582671
  ii specialist teachers of reading and/or educational psychologists outside the school37.7472781

4 assessments of written work?
60.3756497

B Are examples of a child's written work kept from year to year as a progress record, either by the teacher or more centrally?

% YESYesNo
41.7523730


[page 472]

VII The Children's Work

A Which of the following were the subject of poetry, prose or play writing in his/her own words by the sample child ("Albert Aaron") during the week beginning 22 January 1973?

% YESYesNo
1 Original stories81.71,024229
2 Stories or information rewritten in the child's own words84.91,064189
3 Model making or work in art and craft30.6383870
4 Personal investigations in connection with science or mathematics48.2604649
5 Other aspects of the child's daily life in or out of school55.9700553

B When the children are writing in their own words do they

% YESYesNo
1 ask the teacher for help with spelling?96.31,20746
2 use word lists displayed about the room?30.9387866
3 use printed dictionaries, including picture dictionaries?97.41,22033

% YESYesNo
C 1 Is it the practice to give an assessment in writing of at least one piece of written work each week (e.g. 6/10:satisfactory)?43.1540713
2 Are some spelling errors marked each week?97.41,22132
  i Are children expected to learn to spell words from examples of their own errors and/or the errors made by other children in the class and/or lists made by the teacher?95.11,19261
  ii Are the children required to learn to spell words from commercially produced lists?41.4519734


[page 473]

iii Are the children tested to see that they have learnt these spellings

Please tick one box only

% YES
a weekly59.5745
b less often33.1415
c not at all?7.493

% YESYesNo
D 1 Are errors of usage (punctuation, grammar etc.) marked in at least some of the children's writing each week?99.61,2485
2 a Are errors made by the children used as subjects for teaching to the whole class, or to a substantial part of it?85.31,069184
    b Are these errors used as a basis for individual teaching, i.e. teaching the child who made the error?93.71,17479

3 During the week beginning 22 January 1973 was any planned attempt made to extend the children's vocabulary by any of the following means

% YESYesNo
a exercises requiring the use of dictionaries62.7786467
b vocabulary exercises67.0839414
c class discussion based on
  i new materials introduced into the classroom60.0752501
  ii a book or topic chosen partly for that purpose?63.3793460


[page 474]

COMMITTEE OF INQUIRY INTO READING AND THE USE OF ENGLISH

SECONDARY QUESTIONNAIRE

Please ensure that every box or set of boxes is completed, either with a number or with a tick as appropriate.

PART I: SCHOOL SECTION

A GENERAL

LEA ................................... LEA Number ...............
School .............................. School Number ...............
Head ...............................
Telephone ..............................

School Type (please tick one box only)

Modern165
Grammar73
Comprehensive140
Technical5
Other9

Age range of school .................

Youngest child ................. Oldest child .................

Number on roll on 25 January 1973 (i.e. as Form 7)260,579
Number of full-time qualified teachers14,643
Number of part-time qualified teachers1,644
Number of part-time qualified teachers as full-time equivalent (please round to the nearest whole number)809

B THE TEACHERS OF ENGLISH

(For the purposes of this question please disregard drama which is the subject of Question 2 below.)


[page 475]

1 Is the teaching of English organised

Please tick one box only

%
a under a separate English department throughout the school59.7234
b under a separate English department except for remedial classes37.0145
c as part of a department grouping more than one subject1.87
d as part of a department grouping more than one subject but excluding remedial classes0.83
e in none of these ways?0.83

2 Is drama taught in your school

Please tick one box only

%
a as part of the work of the English department84.4331
b under a separate department9.939
c in combination with one or more other subjects (excluding English)4.116
d not at all?1.56

For the remainder of Section B please exclude teachers teaching drama as a subject separate from English.

%
3 a What is the total number of teachers teaching English (including those working with remedial classes)?3,397
  b How many of these are only part-time in the school?9.4318

4 a How many of the teachers teaching English are their first year of teaching?
11.0375
  b How many of the teachers teaching English are in their first year of teaching in this school?23.6803


[page 476]

5 (For the purpose of this question no teacher should be included more than once.)

How many of those teaching English have

%
a an honours degree in English with a post-graduate certificate in Education14.1479
b a degree in which English is one of the subjects, with a post-graduate certificate in Education9.1310
c followed a main or advanced course in English (leading to a teaching certificate or B.Ed.) at College of Education or Education Department of a Polytechnic, for teaching in
  i secondary schools21.9645
  ii junior/secondary schools9.7331
  iii junior schools2.170
d an honours degree in English3.1105
e a degree in which English is one of the subjects3.1105
f a main or advanced course qualification in drama4.0137
g none of the above?32.81,113

6 How many of those teaching English

%
a spend all their teaching time on English37.31,267
b spend more than half their teaching time on English25.2857
c spend up to half their teaching time on English?37.51,273

%
7 How many of those teaching English spend more than a quarter of their time within school in administrative or pastoral work outside the field of English?9.4320


[page 477]

b How many different teachers are represented in the above?

1,104

% YESYesNo
9 a Have any teachers of English made use of a Teachers' Centre in connection with the teaching of English during the past year?71.4280112

  b How many teachers of English are involved in subject panels or committees of examining bodies in connection with English?8.9303


[page 478]

c Does the school or any member of staff belong to

% YESYesNo
i The United Kingdom Reading Association5.421371
ii The National Association for the Teaching of English49.5194198
iii The School Library Association57.1224168
iv The Association for the Education of Pupils from Overseas3.112380
v The English Speaking Board5.622370
vi The Association of Teachers of Speech and Drama?5.622370

C ACCOMMODATION AND FACILITIES FOR ENGLISH

1 How many of the teachers of English

% YES
a teach most of their English in the same room63.12,143
b move to rooms which are class bases to do their English teaching?27.3927

2 a Are any of the following facilities available for the teaching of English?

Please tick where appropriate

% YES
i a drama studio19.175
ii a projection room23.793
iii a recording room13.854
iv a departmental store room70.7277
v a departmental office10.039

% YESYesNo
b Is there any clerical time available for the exclusive use of the English department?3134912


[page 479]

3 Are any of the following available for the teaching of English?

Please tick where appropriate

% YES
a mains tape recorder98.0384
b battery portable tape recorder57.4225
c record player98.2385
d film projector92.1361
e strip/slide/loop projector86.5339
f television set91.3358
g video-tape recorder17.970
h radio82.9325
i reprographic facilities75.5296
j teaching machines (including Language Master and Synchrofax)13.854

D BOOKS AND LIBRARY FACILITIES

1 Is there a central school library ?

Please tick appropriate box

% YES
a Yes, as a single unit77.8305
b Yes, in more than one unit (e.g. an upper and a lower school library)21.283
c No1.04

2 In the last week for how many periods was the library time-tabled for purposes other than library use?

X

3 How many books are there in stock?

Fiction X
Non-fiction X

% YESYesNo
4 Has your school any books on loan from the L.E.A./County/Borough Library?64.0251141


[page 480]

% YESYesNo
5 Do more than half of the rooms where English is taught have class libraries?26.5104288

6 Are there any facilities for the pupils to buy books within the school (e.g. a paperback "book-shop")?
32.4127265

E THE TESTING OF READING ATTAINMENT

1 Are standardised reading tests administered to all or part of the age-group each year:-

Please tick appropriate boxes

Age
group
All
pupils
Some
pupils
No
pupils
There are no pupils of this
age-range in the school
11-12144 39.1%128 34.8%96 26.1%24
12-1335 9.2%216 56.7%130 34.1%11
13-1422 5.8%195 51.5%162 42.7%13
14-1513 3.4%162 42.9%203 53.1%14


[page 481]

2 Please indicate which of the following tests are used for any of these age groups:-

Please tick appropriate boxes

%
Schonell Silent Reading Test A25.5100
Schonell Silent Reading Test B26.8105
Schonell Graded Word Reading Test48.5190
Burt Rearranged Word Reading Test15.360
Holborn Reading Scale25.098
Neale Analysis of Reading Ability17.669
N.F.E.R. Reading Test AD4.618
N.F.E.R. Reading Test EH
    1 Vocabulary4.819
    2 Comprehension5.622
    3 Continuous Prose2.811
N.F.E.R. Reading Comprehension Test DE4.317
Manchester Reading Comprehension Test0.31
Young Group Reading Test2.39
Southgate Group Reading Test 23.112
Other?31.6124

F PROVISION FOR PUPILS WITH READING OR LANGUAGE DIFFICULTIES

If you consider that any of your pupils have special difficulties, please answer the following questions. (please do not include here children whose first language is not English.) If you have no pupils with special difficulties, please continue at Section G.


[page 482]

1 By which of the following methods is special provision made for pupils with reading or language difficulties:

12-13
year age
group
14-15
year age
group
a by withdrawal of individuals or very small groups at certain times of the week for certain purposes194128
b by extraction groups which remain stable for at least a term7937
c remedial classes formed for part of the curriculum in the course of a week5340
d remedial classes (or streams) which have the bulk of their work in those classes but are administered by the main school organisation (i.e. not by a Remedial Department)6359
e remedial classes (or streams) which have bulk of their work in those classes and are administered by a Remedial Department?9855

12-13
year age
group
14-15
year age
group
2 a For what percentage of the total number of pupils in these two age groups are you able to make special provision at the moment?10.4%7.3%
b For what percentage of the total number of pupils in these two age groups do you consider it desirable to have such special provision?12.9%10.2%

YesNoNot
applic-
able
3 Is it a specific part of the responsibility of the head of Remedial Department (or the head of English Department) to advise specialist teachers in other subjects on the needs of pupils with low reading ability?199
50.8%
106
27.0%
87
22.2%


[page 483]

AllMostSomeNoneNot
applic-
able
4 a If there are separate remedial classes (or streams) to which English is taught, do they have regular classroom bases?158
40.3%
37
9.4%
23
5.9%
18
4.6%
156
39.8%
b If there are withdrawal groups for the teaching of reading or language work, do they have suitable accommodation?158
40.3%
40
10.2%
38
9.7%
22
5.6%
134
34.2%

% YESYesNo
5 Have any of the teachers working with these pupils received specific training (initial or in-service) leading to a qualification in the work in which they are involved?50.0%167167

G ENGLISH FOR THE 12-13 AND 14-15 AGE GROUPS

12-1314-15
1 Number of pupils in these age groups55,97855,498

2 How many English teaching groups are there in these age groups?
2,0102,125

3 By what methods are the groups of pupils formed to which English is taught? If there are two or more grouping methods within the year, tick the one to indicate which covers most of the pupils in the year.

12-1314-15
a streamed230184
b setted by English across the whole of the school's ability range116155
c setted by English across a banded section of the school's ability range81160
d mixed ability for the whole of the school's ability range apart from the remedial group13460
e mixed ability for the whole of the school's ability range171162
f mixed ability for a banded section of the school's ability range204144
g according to course or option choice0175
h variable/non-constant312


[page 484]

The Committee of Inquiry would welcome any additional information or opinion which you feel may be of help. A space is provided below.

SECONDARY SCHOOL QUESTIONNAIRE: 12 YEAR OLDS

Explanatory Notes

1. The questionnaire is in two parts, the first of which is concerned with general organisation, staffing facilities, etc. as they relate to the teaching of English.

2. The second part relates to a specific child in each group or class to which English is taught in the 12-13 age-group. Several copies of this section have been enclosed, and an explanation as to how the child should be selected is given on each. The relevant classes for this process are those that contain at least 5 children who were 12 but not 13 on 31 August 1972. If there are fewer than 5 such children in a class it should not be regarded as part of the age-group for the purposes of this survey. In this case it should not be included among the classes from which individual children are being selected. This part of the form should be completed for the selected child in each class by the teacher mainly responsible for the teaching of English to that class. If two or more teachers share the responsibility equally for a class, the teacher whose name is first alphabetically should be the one to complete the form. It would be helpful to the teacher if the L.E.A. and school numbers could be filled in at the head of this form before it is handed over.

3. 25 January has been chosen as the collecting date for certain information because the same figures will need to be returned in Form 7. Unfortunately, it is not possible to use the information directly from Form 7 because the Committee's material will have to be processed before that of Form 7 can be made available.

4. It is expected that this survey will provide information about the range of teaching practices used in English with pupils of the age-group. There is no supposition that the survey will say anything about quality, of which the Committee will gain evidence from visits to a smaller number of schools. Nor will the questionnaire returns from a particular school necessarily represent a full range of the work in that school. It is accepted that where a question has to be answered about an individual child the reply may not be typical even of the class. A large number of schools is included in the survey, and the replies should give a fair picture of what is happening over the country as a whole during the week of the survey. Individual returns from schools will not be quoted.

5. The information given about the school as a whole and about teachers and children will be treated confidentially. The names and telephone numbers have been asked for only in case any query should arise during the processing that requires further information. No names will be transferred to other records.

6. The questionnaire aims to discover what happens in schools. The fact that a question is asked does not imply that the Committee has already adopted a particular view about what should happen.


[page 485]

7. It will be found helpful to read the questionnaire throughout before answering. All questions should be answered by completing the boxes on the right-hand side of each page, entering a number or tick as appropriate. Please ignore the small numbers printed beside some of the boxes. No entries should be made in the right-hand margin.

8. If when completing the questionnaire you should have any difficulty that cannot be resolved in the school, please telephone the Department of Education and Science, Elizabeth House, York Road, London, S.E.1 (telephone 01-928-9222) and ask for the Bullock Committee Survey (ext. 3518).

9. If the number of class sections you have received is insufficient, please ask your L.E.A. for further copies.

PART 2 THE INDIVIDUAL PUPIL: 12-13 AGE GROUP

The purpose of this section is to obtain information about the teaching of English to the 12-13 age-group. Would you please select a single pupil from each of the groups to which English (including English within a remedial context) is taught in this age-group. For each group please answer the questions in relation to the first boy or girl who was present for the whole of the week beginning 22 January 1973 and whose name is first alphabetically (not necessarily first on the register). Separate sheets have been sent for each of these pupils. Please read the section throughout before beginning to answer. You will note that the questions relate to the time the pupil spent on various activities during that week. It is recognised that it may have been an untypical week, but such is the nature of the sample that this will not invalidate the results.

a Name of class or group ..................................
(If the class is known by the name of the teacher, please give that.)

b Is this pupil a

Boy497
Girl442

2 For this pupil is English

Please tick one box only

%
a taught as a separately timetabled subject93.1874
b taught as a separately recognisable element in an integrated scheme4.643
c completely assimilated into an integrated scheme of which it is an indistinguishable element?2.322


[page 486]

3 How many pupils are there in the group in which this pupil has his/her English?

X

% YESYesNo
4 Is this a remedial class or group?11.4107832

Below
average
(bottom
25%)
Average
(middle
50%)
Above
average
(top
25%)
5 How would you assess the reading standard of this pupil in comparison with nationally recognised norms?212
22.6%
499
53.1%
228
24.3%

Questions 6-9: If you have ticked c as the answer to question 2 please do not answer questions 6, 7, 8 and 9 below but continue at question 10.

6 a Total time in minutes allocated to English in respect of this pupil. (Please include drama only if it is taught as an integral part of the work of the English department.)

In
school
Home-
work
20243

b Number of school periods involved

an average of 5.5

7 How many of the English lessons were over an hour's duration?

X

8 Does the teacher who takes this pupil for most of his/her English have:

%
a an honours degree in English with a post-graduate certificate in Education14.4132
b a degree in which English is one of the subjects, with a post-graduate certificate in Education9.486
c a teaching certificate or B.Ed. qualification following a main or advanced course in English at a College of Education or Education Department of a Polytechnic43.0393
d an honours degree in English3.330
e a degree in which English is one of the subjects2.927
f a main or advanced course qualification in drama2.321
g none of the above?24.6225


[page 487]

9 How many teachers are involved in teaching English to this pupil?

an average of 1.4

10 TIME SPENT ON DIFFERENT ACTIVITIES

Writing

a What amount of time during the week beginning 22 January 1973 did this pupil devote to any of the following writing activities? (Please do not indicate the same activity under more than one heading.) The amount of time spent in school should be shown at I and the amount of time allocated for homework should be shown at II.

I In School

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i stories and plays563181152385--
ii from personal experience63019110314--1
iii argument and exposition7611263814---
iv description6931914771--
v reproductive, i.e. writing in pupil's own words of material derived from printed or oral sources60019711023243
vi letters85955231-1-
vii verse7311663921--
viii copying of existing printed material, e.g. for anthologies or topics80210029611-
ix written corrections and fair copying of own work6672561411--


[page 488]

II Homework

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i stories and plays6981766212--
ii from personal experience747156333---
iii argument and exposition8606910----
iv description793126191---
v reproductive, i.e. writing in pupil's own words of material derived from printed or oral sources777134261-1-
vi letters901353----
vii verse866667----
viii copying of existing printed material, e.g. for anthologies or topics903315----
ix written corrections and fair copying of own work8231124----

b Was the writing to

% YESYesNo
i titles set by teacher44.8421518
ii free choice by pupil10.397842
iii free choice by pupil within given themes?57.3538401


[page 489]

c In the correction of the pupil's written work is it the practice to

% YESYesNo
i correct all errors on the work itself23.6222717
ii correct some errors on the work itself71.8674265
iii correct no errors on the work itself2.423916
iv discuss the pupil's errors with him/her individually74.5700239
v require the pupil to write out corrected spellings59.6560379
vi require the pupil to learn to spell correctly words he/she has misspelt?47.6447492

Oral English

What amount of time during the week beginning 22 January 1973 did the pupil devote to any of the following activities?

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i debates, lecturettes and mock interviews82682264-1-
ii a class discussion on topics chosen by teacher4424048931--
  b discussion in small groups on topics chosen by the teacher83587161---
  c class discussion on topics of pupil's own choice8288921---1
  d discussion in small groups on topics of pupil's own choice8923962---
iii a improvised drama609171135222--
  b drama from a printed text80974506---
iv listening to broadcast, record, or tape8081032331-1


[page 490]

Language Study

What amount of time during that week did the pupil devote to any of the following activities? The amount of time spent in school should be shown at I and the amount of time allocated for homework should be shown at II.

I In School

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a grammar exercises71017346631-
  b instruction in usage from errors arising from written work5863331611-2
ii a punctuation exercises787132182---
  b punctuation instruction from errors arising from written work74618931---
iii a vocabulary exercises738175224---
  b vocabulary study arising from written work7861401111--
  c vocabulary study arising from literature72620310----
iv a comprehension exercises6212139392-1
  b comprehension work arising from discussion of literature or other material69019440141--
v a spelling practice from lists859773----
  b spelling practice by dictation of passages909291----
  c spelling practice arising from written work81411861---
  d spelling tests8151204----
vi linguistics-based language study9032610----


[page 491]

II Homework

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a grammar exercises869664----
  b instruction in usage from errors arising from written work90336-----
ii a punctuation exercises896421----
  b punctuation instruction from errors arising from written work912252----
iii a vocabulary exercises8756121---
  b vocabulary study arising from written work883551----
  c vocabulary study arising from literature892461----
iv a comprehension exercises82610751---
  b comprehension work arising from discussion of literature or other material8667021---
v a spelling practice from lists88158-----
  b spelling practice by dictation of passages9381-----
  c spelling practice arising from written work877611----
  d spelling tests92514-----
vi linguistics-based language study927102----


[page 492]

Reading

What amount of time during the week beginning 22 January 1973 did the pupil devote to any of the following activities? The amount of time spent in school should be shown at I and the amount of time allocated for homework should be shown at II.

I In School

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a private reading of fiction49530612513---
  b private reading of non-fiction83492103---
ii private reading of fiction leading to:
  a group discussion914232----
  b class discussion84481122---
iii private reading of non-fiction leading to:
  a group discussion9231321---
  b class discussion9142041---
iv class reading (with teacher) of fiction leading to:
  a group discussion81384402---
  b class discussion492296137131--
v class reading (with teacher) of non-fiction leading to:
  a group discussion9122322---
  b class discussion87255102---
vi a private reading of poetry895431----
  b class reading of poetry (with teacher)655234482---
vii reading for topic, project, or theme work74915726241-
viii reading to improve reading skills707176387623


[page 493]

II Homework

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a private reading of fiction5992546710414
  b private reading of non-fiction896384-1--
ii private reading of poetry906312----
iii private reading of drama92712-----
iv reading for topic, projector theme work809108211---

SECONDARY SCHOOL QUESTIONNAIRE: 14 YEAR OLDS

Explanatory Notes

1 The questionnaire is in two parts, the first of which is concerned with general organisation, staffing facilities, etc. as they relate to the teaching of English.

2 The second part relates to a specific child in each group or class to which English is taught in the 14-15 age-group. Several copies of this section have been enclosed, and an explanation as to how the child should be selected is given on each. The relevant classes for this process are those that contain at least 5 children who were 14 but not 15 on 31 August 1972. If there are fewer than 5 such children in a class it should not be regarded as part of the age-group for the purposes of this survey. In this case it should not be included among the classes from which individual children are being selected. This part of the form should be completed for the selected child in each class by the teacher mainly responsible for the teaching of English to that class. If two or more teachers share the responsibility equally for a class, the teacher whose name is first alphabetically should be the one to complete the form. It would be helpful to the teacher if the L.E.A. and school numbers could be filled in at the head of this form before it is handed over.

3 25 January has been chosen as the collecting date for certain information because the same figures will need to be returned in Form 7. Unfortunately, it is not possible to use the information directly from Form 7 because the Committee's material will have to be processed before that of Form 7 can be made available.


[page 494]

4 It is expected that this survey will provide information about the range of teaching practices used in English with pupils of the age-group. There is no supposition that the survey will say anything about quality, of which the Committee will gain evidence from visits to a smaller number of schools. Nor will the questionnaire returns from a particular school necessarily represent a full range of the work in that school. It is accepted that where a question has to be answered about an individual child the reply may not be typical even of the class. A large number of schools is included in the survey, and the replies should give a fair picture of what is happening. over the country as a whole during the week of the survey. Individual returns from schools will not be quoted.

5 The information given about the school as a whole and about teachers and children will be treated confidentially. The names and telephone numbers have been asked for only in case any query should arise during the processing that requires further information. No names will be transferred to other records.

6 The questionnaire aims to discover what happens in schools. The fact that a question is asked does not imply that the Committee has already adopted a particular view about what should happen.

7 It will be found helpful to read the questionnaire throughout before answering. All questions should be answered by completing the boxes on the right-hand side of each page, entering a number or tick as appropriate. Please ignore the small numbers printed beside some of the boxes. No entries should be made in the right-hand margin.

8 If when completing the questionnaire you should have any difficulty that cannot be resolved in the school, please telephone the Department of Education and Science, Elizabeth House, York Road, London, S.E.l (telephone 01-928-9222) and ask for the Bullock Committee Survey (ext 3518).

9 If the number of class sections you have received is insufficient, please ask your L.E.A. for further copies.

PART 2 THE INDIVIDUAL PUPIL: 14-15 AGE GROUP

The purpose of this section is to obtain information about the teaching of English to the 14-15 age-group. Would you please select a single pupil from each of the groups to which English (including English within a remedial context) is taught in this age-group. For each group please answer the questions in relation to the first boy or girl who was present for the whole of the week beginning 22 January 1973 and whose name is first alphabetically (not necessarily first on the register). Separate sheets have been sent for each of these pupils. Please read the section throughout before beginning to answer. You will note that the questions relate to the time the pupil spent on various activities during that week. It is recognised that it may have been an untypical week, but such is the nature of the sample that this will not invalidate the results.


[page 495]

a Name of class or group ..................................
(If the class is known by the name of the teacher, please give that.)

b Is this pupil a

Boy578
Girl474

2 For this pupil is English

Please tick one box only

%
a taught as a separately timetabled subject93.8987
b taught as a separately recognisable element in an integrated scheme2.930
c completely assimilated into an integrated scheme of which it is an indistinguishable element?3.335

3 How many pupils are there in the group in which this pupil has his/her English?

X

4 Is this group

Please tick one box only

%
a in the first year of a 2-year "O" level course21.5226
b in the first year of a 2-year C.S.E. course32.2339
c in the first year of a course which may culminate in either "O" level or C.S.E. for some or all of the pupils29.5310
d on a course which culminates in "O" level in Summer Term 19731.617
e on a course which leads to no examination10.2107
f a remedial class or group?5.053

(If English is one component of a group of subjects which are examined together, e.g. as Humanities, please regard it as a separate subject for the purpose of the above question.)

Below
average
(bottom
25%)
Average
(middle
50%)
Above
average
(top
25%)
5 How would you assess the reading standard of this pupil in comparison with nationally recognised norms?211563278
20.1%53.5%26.4%

Questions 6-9: If you have ticked c as the answer to question 2 please do not answer questions 6, 7,8 and 9 below but continue at question 10.


[page 496]

6 a Total time in minutes allocated to English in respect of this pupil. (Please include drama only if it is taught as an integral part of the work of the English department.)

In
school
Home-
work
19659

b Number of school periods involved

an average of 5.25

7 How many of the English lessons were over an hour's duration?

X

8 Does the teacher who takes this pupil for most of his/her English have:

%
a an honours degree in English with a post-graduate certificate in Education22.5229
b a degree in which English is one of the subjects, with a post-graduate certificate in Education12.3126
c a teaching certificate or B.Ed. qualification following a main or advanced course in English at a College of Education or Education Department of a Polytechnic38.1387
d an honours degree in English4.344
e a degree in which English is one of the subjects1.818
f a main or advanced course qualification in drama2.626
g none of the above?18.4187

9 How many teachers are involved in teaching English to this pupil?

an average of 1.2

10 Time spent on different activities

Writing a What amount of time during the week beginning 22 January 1973 did this pupil devote to any of the following writing activities? (Please do not indicate the same activity under more than one heading.) The amount of time spent in school should be shown at I and the amount of time allocated for homework should be shown at II.


[page 497]

I In School

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i stories and plays78212310333731
ii from personal experience759167104183-1
iii argument and exposition786165821531-
iv description81813981131--
v reproductive, i.e. writing in pupil's own words of material derived from printed or oral sources674183141401013
vi letters92884337---
vii verse943772741--
viii copying of existing printed material, e.g. for anthologies or topics951603110---
ix written corrections and fair copying of own work845195111---

II Homework

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i stories and plays8599776107-3
ii from personal experience8411277842--
iii argument and exposition86398829---
iv description90891485---
v reproductive, i.e. writing in pupil's own words of material derived from printed or oral sources853116681311-
vi letters9954512----
vii verse99538172---
viii copying of existing printed material, e.g. for anthologies or topics10073411----
ix written corrections and fair copying of own work961846-1--


[page 498]

b Was the writing to

% YESYesNo
i titles set by teacher54.1570482
ii free choice by pupil10.4109943
iii free choice by pupil within given themes?49.6522530

c In the correction of the pupil's written work is it the practice to

% YESYesNo
i correct all errors on the work itself31.0326726
ii correct some errors on the work itself64.5679373
iii correct no errors on the work itself1.7181034
iv discuss the pupil's errors with him/her individually78.3824228
v require the pupil to write out corrected spellings41.1432620
vi require the pupil to learn to spell correctly words he/she has misspelt?40.5426626

Oral English

What amount of time during the week beginning 22 January 1973 did the pupil devote to any of the following activities?

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i debates, lecturettes and mock interviews92187346112
ii a class discussion on topics chosen by teacher4573951751951-
  b discussion in small groups on topics chosen by the teacher910119176---
  c class discussion on topics of pupil's own choice94481252---
  d discussion in small groups on topics of pupil's own choice99046132---
iii a improvised drama937683115--1
  b drama from a printed text78911711823311
iv listening to broadcast, record, or tape845129641031-


[page 499]

Language Study

What amount of time during that week did the pupil devote to any of the following activities? The amount of time spent in school should be shown at I and the amount of time allocated for homework should be shown at II.

I In School

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a grammar exercises944871461--
  b instruction in usage from errors arising from written work75328514----
ii a punctuation exercises94296131---
  b punctuation instruction from errors arising from written work8911565----
iii a vocabulary exercises855167282---
  b vocabulary study arising from written work9021437----
  c vocabulary study arising from literature8392085----
iv a comprehension exercises710197122221--
  b comprehension work arising from discussion of literature or other material70526769101--
v a spelling practice from lists1019312----
  b spelling practice by dictation of passages10262321---
  c spelling practice arising from written work960884----
  d spelling tests976733----
vi linguistics-based language study10222172---


[page 500]

II Homework

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a grammar exercises10142612----
  b instruction in usage from errors arising from written work1025261----
ii a punctuation exercises1019312----
  b punctuation instruction from errors arising from written work103616-----
iii a vocabulary exercises9796571---
  b vocabulary study arising from written work1021274----
  c vocabulary study arising from literature1020301-1--
iv a comprehension exercises916110241---
  b comprehension work arising from discussion of literature or other material946901411--
v a spelling practice from lists1029185----
  b spelling practice by dictation of passages10502-----
  c spelling practice arising from written work102428-----
  d spelling tests104471----
vi linguistics-based language study104381----


[page 501]

Reading

What amount of time during the week beginning 22 January 1973 did the pupil devote to any of the following activities? The amount of time spent in school should be shown at I and the amount of time allocated for homework should be shown at II.

I In School

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a private reading of fiction64023815113217
  b private reading of non-fiction96070211---
ii private reading of fiction leading to:
  a group discussion1025188-1--
  b class discussion94685192---
iii private reading of non-fiction leading to:
  a group discussion1030202----
  b class discussion1010375----
iv class reading (with teacher) of fiction leading to:
  a group discussion929684852--
  b class discussion643224158204-3
v class reading (with teacher) of non-fiction leading to:
  a group discussion1032173----
  b class discussion976561811--
vi a private reading of poetry1016315----
  b class reading of poetry (with teacher)811179611---
vii reading for topic, project, or theme work8451504971--
viii reading to improve reading skills91499326-1-


[page 502]

II Homework

Minutes
01-
30
31-
60
61-
90
91-
120
121-
150
Over
150
i a private reading of fiction6322511182213412
  b private reading of non-fiction98238166424
ii private reading of poetry9955331---
iii private reading of drama100233123--2
iv reading for topic, projector theme work853149405122

Chapter 25 Part III | Chapter 25 Part V